How to deal with a fake negative review

Andrew Hurrell • June 1, 2017

This is probably a business owner’s worst nightmare, I suppose.

It’s because fake reviews, or negative reviews, can cause you damage and how you deal with them depends on how much damage they cause.

I’ve come across a really good example of how to respond to a fake, negative review. And just let me explain, this review that I’m going to show you isn’t fake in regards to that it’s real. It’s real because Google have allowed it to go on there and this somebody has an Google account. In my opinion, I believe that it’s not a customer of this business. My experience tells me, in reputation management, that this person didn’t do any business with this company. Anyway, let’s crack on; let’s show you what I mean.

I came across this because we were doing a little bit of research.

Double glazing in Poole is a search that I’ve typed in into Google and so the usual comes up, the ads and then you’ve got the three-pack.

Now, Seyward Window Company Limited has three reviews, so on the surface of it, you think, yes, that’s good.

But once you click through to the company to find out more where you can check out their reviews…

So a chap has wrote a really condemning review. It’s real, but I believe that he hasn’t dealt with this business and it’s as in his review he says “ Cowboys selling inferior products.”

It just goes on, even in capital letters, “ DO NOT DEAL UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES” pretty condemning.

And the business owner has obviously come across this and responded, rightly so, in my opinion. This is one of the best responses that this business owner could have come back with because he’s addressed the issue; he hasn’t left it out there for people to make their own conclusion, which would have been the wrong thing. And he’s put, “Dear Mr Pullen, I’ve checked our records and it appears we don’t have your name listed as a previous customer but I would be more than happy to deal with your problem if you could call us on blah, blah, blah.

So the business owner sort of made it clear that this Mr Pullen is fictitious in regards to he hasn’t dealt with his company and he’s put his side across.

So if you get what I call a fake, negative review, so it’s somebody who hasn’t dealt with you, then it might not be a bad idea to do what this business owner did and write a little, short response, rather than leave it out there for people to make their own minds up as to whether or not it’s negative, which would be the wrong thing to do. So congratulations to that business owner.

I thought that may well help yourselves as it’s a good little tip. So that’s just a good way of how to respond to a fake, negative review.


I hope the above article was of interest and you found it useful.


If you need our help, then please arrange a call with me.

ARRANGE A CALL
Andrew Hurrell Customer Feedback Centre online reputation management

Author: Andrew Hurrell


No Reviews As Of Today: Is a Business with No Online Reviews Trustworthy? ?
By Andrew Hurrell April 30, 2025
Can you trust a business with zero reviews in 2025? Discover why some great companies lack online feedback and how to fix this crucial trust signal in today's digital world. 🌟
Why Google Reviews Alone Won't Cut It Anymore ?
By Andrew Hurrell April 24, 2025
If you're scratching your head about managing reviews across different platforms without losing your marbles, we can explain a simple method for gathering and spreading your reviews evenly across different platforms.
Direct Feedback vs 3rd Party Reviews - What's Actually Worth Your Time?
By Andrew Hurrell April 22, 2025
Discover which review strategy actually works for local businesses: direct feedback or third-party reviews? Learn practical, tested approaches to collecting both types of reviews effectively, with examples from UK businesses. Get actionable tips to boost your online reputation.
Should You Report Your Competitors' Fake Google Reviews? Here's The Truth
By Andrew Hurrell April 22, 2025
Discover the right way to handle fake Google reviews from competitors. Learn when and how to report suspicious reviews, plus actionable strategies to build an authentic online reputation that lasts.
Reviews: The Honest Truth
By Andrew Hurrell April 10, 2025
From pub recommendations to Google reviews. See how local businesses are winning customers in today’s world. Get your happy customers' feedback working for you!
Why Reviews Matter (and Why You Should Really Care)
By Andrew Hurrell April 10, 2025
If you don’t have any Google Reviews or even worse, just one dodgy review then you’re getting scrolled past faster than you can say “please call me.
It's Time To Stop Hiding Your Best Reviews!
By Andrew Hurrell April 2, 2025
Don't hide your customer reviews! When you showcase feedback on your website, potential customers can see how much your existing clients love your work.
Getting Reviews Doesn't Need to Be a Hassle! ?
By Andrew Hurrell April 2, 2025
We make it super easy for your customers to write you reviews. Get those reviews shouting out how great you are so all potential customers to see.
Why Your Customers Should Do Your Marketing
By Andrew Hurrell March 25, 2025
Turn happy customers into your best marketers! Get them talking online and win more business. Simple steps, big results. Call us today!
Show More